How to Screen Rental Residents the Right Way in Riverside, California (2025 Guide)

Publish Your Screening Criteria Before You Take an Application — and the Fee Is Capped at About $65

By BRIAN BEAN
Rental Home Advocate | Property Manager | Real Estate Broker

If you own a rental property in Southern California, resident screening is the single most important step you can take to protect your investment. It directly impacts your income, your property’s condition, and your peace of mind. But to do it right, you need to follow California’s screening laws—and you need to do it fairly and consistently.

In this guide, we’ll break down the screening process we use at Dream Big Property Management, based in Riverside, California. Whether you’re a DIY landlord or just want to understand how placement decisions are made, this will help you stay compliant and make better, more intentional choices.

Why Screening Matters

Placing the wrong resident can cost you tens of thousands of dollars in unpaid rent, legal fees, property damage, and stress. But placing the right resident? That leads to on-time rent, lease compliance, better communication, and a stronger investment experience overall.

It all starts with proper screening.

California Tenant Screening Laws (2025)

Before we dive into the steps, here are key legal guidelines you must follow:

  • Fair Housing Compliance – You cannot screen or reject applicants based on race, gender, religion, disability, family status, source of income (including Section 8), or immigration status, among other factors.
  • Written Screening Criteria (Civil Code §1950.6) – With the passage of new legislation, landlords must disclose rental qualifications in writing in their marketing information or with their applications, before accepting applications. This is to provide property transparency to applicants about what qualifications they must meet to be approved.
  • Application Fee Limits – California limits application fees to ~$65 per applicant in 2025. In many cases, landlords also must refund full or partial fees for to applicants who were not selected. (Dream Big Property Management does not charge application fees, to reduce barriers and encourage more applicants.)

Our 6-Step Screening Process

Step 1: The Application

Our online rental application collects all pertinent identifying information and history for an applicant, age 19 or older. But we also specifically request:

  • 10 years of rental history
  • Employment and income details
  • Personal references
  • An applicant-supplied copy of a recent credit check from a major reporting bureau.

Step 2: Credit Check

We don’t use a minimum credit score cutoff. But, from the applicants’ credit reports, we look for:

  • History of on-time payments
  • No more than 4 collection accounts
  • No more than $1,000 in non-medical collections

Step 3: Background Check

If the applicant passes the pre-screening evaluation of their credit report, we will pull our own copy of a full background check.

  • We review recent and relevant criminal convictions, focusing on offenses related to people or property.
  • Evictions are an automatic disqualification (unless related to domestic violence or threats to the occupant)

Step 4: Income & Employment

Applicants must show:

  • Gross income of 3x rent, or
  • Net income of 2x rent plus any recurring consumer debt payments

As proof of income, we can accept:

  • 60 days of pay stubs
  • 2 years of W-2s
  • Income award or job offer letters
  • 3 months of bank statements (all pages)
  • For self-employed applicants:
    • 2 years of personal tax returns + 6 months of bank statements
  • A bank statement that shows enough funds to cover all move-in costs.
  • We contact employers to confirm current work status

Step 5: Landlord References

We ask current and previous landlords (as far back as 10 years) for their experience with an applicant:

  • Did the applicant pay rent on time?
  • Did they maintain the property?
  • Did they follow the lease terms?
  • Did they follow the lease terms?
  • Were there any complaints about them from other residents?
  • Did they have pets?
  • Would you rent to them again?

Step 6: Pets & Assistance Animals

  • If pets are allowed, we ask about breed, size, age, bite history, and vet records, among other factors.
  • Service animals and emotional support animals are not considered pets and may not be denied. In those cases, we use a third-party service to collect and verify documentation.

Red Flags to Watch For

  • Incomplete applications
  • Eviction history
  • Pattern of short-term tenancies
  • Faked documentation (especially pay stubs, which have become more common). Document fraud detection tools are a must in today’s environment.

Final Thoughts

Finding, screening, and placing the right resident is the most crucial — and often most difficult — part of property management. But when done right, it leads to better outcomes:

  • On-time rent
  • Long-term tenancy
  • Less stress
  • Fewer vacancies
  • More predictable returns

At Dream Big, we believe great residents don’t happen by accident. They’re the result of a clear, fair, and intentional screening process.

Have Questions?

If you have questions about screening rental applicants, or if you’d like help finding tools to screen residents fairly, we’re happy to help.

Call Brian at 951-314-5402, or visit DreamBigPM.com

Related Reading

Full Transcript

Transcript of the video above — Brian Bean, Broker/Owner and Rental Home Advocate, Dream Big Property Management. CA DRE #01346382. Lightly edited for readability.

Hi, I’m Brian Bean with Dream Big Property Management here in Riverside, California. Last week we talked about how great residents affect your experience as a rental homeowner. Today we’re walking through how to actually find, screen, and choose your next renters. Screening residents the right way protects you, your property, your finances, and your peace of mind. But you must follow local, state, and federal laws, or you face some serious risk. And frankly, why wouldn’t you want to be in compliance while treating people fairly at the same time anyway? So we’re talking about staying out of trouble, staying out of court, and doing the right thing.

So let’s break this down. First, the law. Fair housing guidelines paved the way for California landlords. They’re the rules of the road. It means not discriminating based on race, gender, religion, disability, familial status, source of income, or immigration status.

Here are some more laws that came into effect this year that are important to know as well. As of 2025, you must provide screening criteria in writing before accepting applications. And there are limits on application fees: California allows up to $65 per applicant, and in many cases you must also refund all or part of those fees to applicants who were not selected. We decided at Dream Big earlier this year to completely eliminate application fees, to remove barriers and encourage more applications.

Now let’s walk through some of the steps of a solid screening process. Step one, the application. Among the items that we collect is 10 years of rental history, employment info, income details, and references. We’re asking applicants to provide a recent background check report as well, as part of the pre-screening, though we will still pull our own to confirm accuracy.

Credit checks. We don’t have a minimum credit score requirement, but we do focus on credit activity. What has been the history? Do bills get paid on time? If there’s more than four collections, or more than a thousand dollars in non-medical collections, that can disqualify an applicant.

Background checks. We review recent and relevant criminal convictions. Crimes related to people or property can affect an applicant’s qualifications. As well, evictions are an automatic disqualification — except if they were related to domestic violence or threats to an occupant.

Income and employment. We look for gross income of three times rent, or alternatively a net income of two times rent plus any required consumer debt payments. As evidence of income, we’ll accept 60 days’ pay stubs, two years’ W-2s, income award letters, three months’ bank statements, or for self-employed applicants, two years’ personal tax returns and six months’ personal bank statements. We do not accept any business bank statements or tax returns as evidence of income. Applicants also must show that they have reserves to cover move-in funds — usually a bank statement will show sufficient funds for that. And yes, we do contact employers to confirm you are currently working.

Current and past landlord references are critical. We ask: did they pay rent on time? Did they care for the property? Did they abide by the terms of the lease? And would you rent to them again?

And as far as pets go — pets and assistance animals. Not all property owners allow pets, but when they do, we ask about the animal’s breed, size, and bite history, and we do require vet records. Service and emotional support animals are not considered pets by law, and they cannot just be denied. In those instances, we use a screening service to gather and verify documentation as we go through the screening process.

These are some red flags that we watch for: incomplete applications, evictions, frequent moves, and fake documentation, which unfortunately has become very prevalent. To ferret that out, we use tools to flag document fraud, and we have third-party vendors who provide that service for us.

So why do we go through all of this? Because finding, screening, and placing a resident is the most crucial and often most difficult task that we do in property management. If we get that wrong, it could cost you, the owner, thousands — tens of thousands of dollars — in lost rent, repairs, or legal trouble. But when we place the right residents, you see the rewards: on-time rent, good communication, long-term tenancy, and residents who take care of your property.

Great residents will directly shape your experience as a rental investor. When residents feel respected and connected to their home, you’ll have fewer problems, less stress, lower vacancy, and better financial returns. But it all starts with proper tenant screening.

If you have questions about anything we’ve talked about today, or you’d like resources for tools you can use to screen tenants on your own, call me today at 951-314-5402 or visit us at dreambigpm.com. Don’t be accidental about your future. Be intentional to your success.