Should You Hire a Property Manager or Manage Your Riverside CA Rental Property Yourself?
There Are Three Options, Not Two — and the Right One Changes Over Time
By BRIAN BEAN
Rental Home Advocate | Property Manager | Real Estate Broker
Here’s how to choose the right approach for your Inland Empire investment.
If you’re a landlord — or considering becoming one — you’ve probably asked yourself:
“Should I hire a property manager, or manage my rental myself?”
It’s a big decision. And there’s no one-size-fits-all answer.
Whether you own a single-family home in Riverside or a small portfolio in the Inland Empire, the best choice depends on your goals, availability, risk tolerance, and support system.
In this post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of self-management, the benefits of hiring a professional property manager, and a third “hybrid” option that gives you flexibility and control.
Option 1: Self-Managing Your Rental Property
Self-management can be a great fit if:
- You live near your rental property
- You have time to be hands-on
- You’re willing to learn the ins and outs of the business
The Upside:
- No management fees — you keep 100% of the rent
- Full control over decisions, repairs, and tenant selection
- Personal relationships with your residents and vendors
The Challenges:
- You’re responsible for everything — leasing, maintenance, accounting, legal compliance, and customer service
- You need to stay current on local, state, and federal housing laws
- You’re on call — nights, weekends, and holidays
- You’ll need to find and vet vendors for every repair or emergency
Good News: You’re not completely alone.
If you self-manage, check out the following resources:
- California Apartment Association (CAA) for legislative updates
- BiggerPockets Landlord Forums to learn from other self-managing Investors
Option 2: Hiring a Property Manager
A property management company takes over the daily responsibilities of running your rental, giving you back your time — and your peace of mind.
The Benefits:
- Handles leasing, maintenance, resident communication, and accounting
- Ensures legal compliance and reduces liability
- Shields you from stress and late-night calls
- Often reduces maintenance costs through vendor volume discounts
- Helps prevent costly mistakes (such as fair housing violations or bad tenant screening)
The Drawbacks:
- You’ll pay a monthly management fee (usually a percentage of collected rent)
- Not all property managers are created equal — research, interview, and ask good questions
- You’ll typically have less day-to-day control, which can be a psychological barrier for some owners
💡 Pro Tip:
Before hiring a property management company, download 25 Questions to Hire a Property Manager to help you interview candidates.
Option 3: Hybrid Management (Find a Solution to the Precise Problem)
Hybrid management is a growing trend — and for good reason.
This approach lets you keep the tasks you enjoy or are best at and outsource the rest. It’s ideal for owners who want to stay involved but need backup where it counts.
Examples of Hybrid Management:
- You handle leasing; a PM handles maintenance
- You collect rent; a PM issues legal notices and does inspections
- You manage day-to-day operations, but your PM handles annual services such as preventive maintenance, inspections, or lease renewals
This option gives you customized support while maintaining control.
So What’s the Right Choice for You?
Here are some questions to ask yourself:
- Do I have time to manage the property well?
- Am I confident in staying compliant with California’s rental laws?
- Do I have a trusted network for maintenance and repairs?
- What is my stress tolerance — and how much is my time worth?
The answer might change over time — and that’s okay.
You can always start with self-management and shift to a manager later. Or vice versa.
Need Help Deciding?
Use Dream Big Property Management as one of those resources.
We’re happy to answer questions, share strategy ideas, or help you determine if professional management is right for you.
Call or text Brian Bean directly at 951-314-5402, or visit us at DreamBigPM.com
No pressure. No pitch. Just real help.
Related reading: How to Choose the Right Property Manager in Riverside: 7 Traits to Look For
Full Transcript
Transcript of the video above — Brian Bean, Broker/Owner and Rental Home Advocate, Dream Big Property Management. CA DRE #01346382. Lightly edited for readability.
Hi, I’m Brian Bean with Dream Big Property Management here in Riverside, California. If you own a rental property or you’re thinking about becoming a rental property investor, you’ve probably contemplated the question: should I hire a property manager, or should I just manage it myself? It’s a big decision. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. So let’s walk through some of the pros and the cons of each path, plus discuss a third option that you might not even have thought about.
Option one, self-management. Self-management can work well if you live near the property, if you have extra time, and if you’re willing to invest the effort to learn the business. The upside is you don’t have to pay management fees, and those fees are usually based on the rent collected each month. You have total control to make your own decisions, including whom to lease to, which handyman to hire, what to charge for rent, and you get to build direct relationships with your residents and with your vendors.
On the downside, people typically default to the three T’s of rental homes: tenants, toilets, and trash. Though property management on some days is more challenging than others, typically it’s really not that dramatic.
Here’s what you should expect, however, if you are self-managing. You wear every hat: leasing, management, operations, maintenance, accounting, admin, customer service, marketing, and most importantly, compliance. You absolutely must stay up to date on local, state, and federal laws that affect you, your rental property, your residents, and your ability to run your business. You’re on call nights, weekends, holidays. Problems arise after hours or on weekends because that’s when your residents are home from work, and that’s when they call. And it’s on you to find, interview, and vet vendors for maintenance and repairs, and to negotiate those costs yourself.
Now, you’re not totally alone if you choose to self-manage. There’s many resources out there. There’s many communities that are designed to help people in your situation. We would recommend the California Apartment Association — they give great legislative updates — and BiggerPockets has forums where you can learn from other people who are doing what you’re trying to learn.
Now, hiring a property manager. Here are the pros. Property managers handle leasing, maintenance, accounting, marketing, legal compliance, resident communication. You spend your time on more important things than chasing down rent or trying to get a plumber out for a leak. Your property manager shields you from the many day-to-day issues that come up, reducing your stress. And they also help prevent costly mistakes, such as fair housing violations or choosing the wrong tenants. Maintenance costs are often lower because property management companies typically get volume discounts from their vendors, and that saves you in the long run.
Now, the downside of hiring a PM starts with the cost. You’ll pay a monthly fee, usually based off the rent collected. Not all PMs are created equal. You can’t just hire one because they have a current state license. You may have to research multiple companies, check references, and interview them to make sure that you understand what they do and what they do not do. We’ll have a link in the description below with a list of questions that you can ask any property manager before you hire one. Also, you have less control over daily operations, which can be a tough psychological hurdle for some owners.
Now, option three, hybrid management. Hybrid management is when you keep some tasks and you outsource others. For instance, you might handle leasing, but you hire help for maintenance. You might collect rent, but let someone else handle legal notices and inspections. Or you might hire a property manager for a concierge-like service for as-needed tasks such as annual inspections, leasing and tenant renewals, or preventive maintenance programs. This option is more flexible, but it fills the gaps where you need it most.
So whether you self-manage, whether you hire a property manager, or whether you go hybrid, the goal is clarity. Know your strengths. Acknowledge your limits. Evaluate what your time is worth. Make use of resources like CAA, BiggerPockets, or have conversations with other landlords, including us.
If you have questions about anything we’ve talked about today, or you want to talk about different strategies, give me a call directly at 951-314-5402. No pressure, no pitch. I’m happy to help. You can also visit us at dreambigpm.com. Thank you for watching.
To your success.
