Stop Bidding Yourself into Higher Repair Costs: Why Multiple Quotes Cost Inland Empire Property Investors More Money

Part 4 of our 4-Part Maintenance Mastery Series

Under $500, We Just Fix It — and That Beats Waiting on a Second Quote

By BRIAN BEAN
Rental Home Advocate | Property Manager | Real Estate Broker

Many rental property owners across the Inland Empire think they’re being financially savvy by requesting multiple quotes for every repair. After all, competition drives down prices, right? Unfortunately, when it comes to routine maintenance and time-and-materials repairs, this approach often costs investors significantly more money than it saves.

The Hidden Costs of the Multiple Quote Mentality

Service Call Fees Add Up Fast: Most contractors don’t provide free estimates. If they don’t get the job, you’ll likely receive a bill for their service call — typically $75-150 per visit. Getting three quotes on a $600 repair can cost $300 in estimate fees before any work begins.

Damage Compounds During Delays: While you’re waiting for multiple estimates, problems get worse. A small leak becomes floor damage. A broken disposal creates unhappy residents. Time isn’t neutral in maintenance — it’s expensive.

Resident Satisfaction Plummets: Residents don’t care about your bidding process. They care about getting their home fixed quickly. Delays create frustration, and frustrated residents become uncooperative or start looking for new places to live. Vacancy costs far exceed any potential savings from shopping quotes.

Vendor Relationships Suffer: When you send multiple contractors to bid on routine work, two of them won’t get the job. Next time you need service, those vendors may charge more for estimates, deprioritize your calls, or stop responding entirely. They don’t feel valued because, frankly, you don’t value them enough.

When Multiple Quotes Make Sense (And When They Don’t)

Get Multiple Quotes For:

  • HVAC system replacements
  • Roof replacements
  • Major plumbing projects
  • Large renovation work

These big-ticket items have significant differences in price, material quality, and warranties. The time spent comparison shopping is justified by potential savings.

Skip Multiple Quotes For:

  • Toilet replacements
  • Garbage disposal repairs
  • Basic plumbing repairs
  • Standard electrical work
  • Routine HVAC maintenance

Time-and-materials repairs typically yield similar costs regardless of contractor. Parts come from the same suppliers, and experienced professionals charge comparable rates for standard work.

Real Examples from Inland Empire Properties

The $1,000 Mistake One client recently struggled with this concept. Her vacant rental ($3,000/month) needed paint, carpet, and small handyman tasks like installing towel racks and replacing locksets. She got second opinions on paint and carpet (appropriate for larger costs) but insisted on quotes for the small items. The extra 10 days waiting for estimates cost $1,000 in lost rent — far more than any potential savings.

The $375 Success Story Another property had a non-functioning toilet in a one-bathroom home. Our handyman replaced it same-day for $375. Could we have saved $50 by shopping around? Possibly. But residents would have been without a working toilet for additional days, and there’s no good way to explain that delay.

The $1,500 Emergency A resident reported water seeping from both sides of a wall. Our team opened the wall same-day, found a pressurized water line leak, fixed the pipe, and immediately started drying equipment. Total initial cost: $1,500. No preapproval. No second opinions. The time needed for multiple quotes would have created a mold remediation situation costing thousands more.

The GSD System: Get Stuff Done

We’ve developed a simple decision-making framework that eliminates costly delays while protecting against surprise expenses:

Under $500: Immediate approval. Fix it and send the bill.

Over $500: Call for approval from the worksite before proceeding.

Emergency situations: Stop damage first, regardless of cost. Regroup later for logical, less-stressful completion.

This system saves time and money, keeps residents satisfied, and strengthens vendor relationships — which absolutely translates to preferred pricing for our clients.

Building Valuable Vendor Relationships

Great vendors save you money through reliability, quality work, and preferred pricing. When you have a trusted handyman who knows you always call them, they’ll rearrange their schedule, maintain your properties efficiently, and offer competitive rates because they know they’re likely to get the work.

But if you’re just using vendors to drive down someone else’s price, don’t expect preferred treatment or pricing. Loyalty works both ways in the contractor relationship.

The Bottom Line for Inland Empire Property Investors

Repairs and maintenance represent one of the most important but often mismanaged aspects of rental property ownership. The costs touch every segment of your residents, property, and profitability. Handle them incorrectly, and you risk unpleasant legal complications, unhappy residents, and unnecessary expenses.

Speed saves money. Happy residents stay longer, pay on time, and take better care of your property. Great vendor relationships provide reliability and preferred pricing. A systematic approach to maintenance decisions eliminates the bottlenecks that turn routine repairs into expensive problems.

Don’t bid yourself into higher costs. Focus on speed, relationships, and systematic decision-making. Your residents, your vendors, and your bottom line will thank you.

Get Maintenance Off Your Plate

If chasing quotes and coordinating handymen has become a second job, that is what we do all day. Call Brian Bean directly at 951-314-5402, or reach the office at 951-778-9700, and we will walk through how the GSD threshold would work on your property. You can also run your own numbers first with our free ROI Calculator.

We serve rental property investors throughout the Inland Empire, including Riverside, Moreno Valley, Corona, San Bernardino, and surrounding communities.

The Complete Maintenance Mastery Series

Related Reading

Full Transcript

Transcript of the video above — Brian Bean, Broker/Owner and Rental Home Advocate, Dream Big Property Management. CA DRE #01346382. Lightly edited for readability.

Many rental property owners think they need multiple quotes for every repair, but they are unknowingly driving up their cost. I’m going to share one simple rule that will keep your repair cost down and ensure that your handyman shows up.

Hi, I’m Brian Bean with Dream Big Property Management here in Riverside, California. This is the last piece of our four-part Maintenance Mastery Series. Today we’re talking about a common but expensive mistake that many mom-and-pop investors make. Multiple quotes for every single repair call.

In part two of this series, you learned why fix fast is always cheaper than fix slow. It reduces damage, reduces cost, creates happy residents who stay longer. They pay on time. They’re going to take better care of your property. A lot of investors have trouble achieving that goal. They may want to fix fast, but they get in their own way. They order up multiple bids on everything, even the smallest repair.

And I get that. Seems logical that if you want to save money, you get more than one opinion. But maybe somebody will do it cheaper, right? The problem is it ends up costing you more in the long run. Here’s how.

Time and materials repairs. The smaller routine stuff isn’t going to yield much lower cost from one handyman to the next. The parts are going to be about the same price regardless of who drives to Home Depot to pick them up. And the estimate for the cost of labor is really just an educated guess based on the symptoms. Once they get into that job, if they find something else that was unknown, it’s going to cost more, guaranteed.

Ultimately, requesting multiple quotes just ends up taking more time and in the process increasing cost. The most obvious way is when damage is accruing because something hasn’t been fixed yet and it’s going to cost more to fix it. The other you’re going to see right out of the gate. Handymen and contractors do not spend their days giving out free quotes. If you send them to give a quote and they don’t get the job, you’re getting a bill for that service call. That’s an extra hundred bucks or so, and the work hasn’t even started yet.

There are two other intangible problems. They’re hard to see in the moment, but they can have a significant impact down the road.

The first we’ve talked about at length. It’s so important, though, that I really can’t repeat it enough. The longer it takes to get something fixed, the more frustrated your residents become. Unhappy residents become uncooperative residents. And if there’s a pattern of delays, your residents will look for another home and you’ll be dealing with a much more expensive problem, vacancy.

The other is the impact on your vendor relationship. When you send multiple handymen to quote a job, they may get out there to take a look at it really quick, but the next time you have a repair, those same vendors are likely going to charge you more. They’re not going to prioritize you, or they may not respond at all, because they do not feel valued by you. And the fact is you do not value them enough.

Great vendors save you money. If you have a regular handyman and you trust them and they trust you, when you call, they rearrange their schedule. They get things fixed quickly and they give you great prices because they know that you always call them. But if you’re just using them to get the price down on somebody else, don’t expect them to play along and don’t expect their preferred customer pricing.

Now, I’m not talking about big ticket items here. Larger projects or price tags often call for a second opinion. Issues like HVAC replacement, a new roof, or a large plumbing project. For large projects, there will be differences in price, material quality, and warranty. It only makes sense to have a second opinion. But when a garbage disposal dies, this does not warrant more than one estimate. A routine repair such as swapping out a small appliance is going to cost about the same, regardless of whom you send. The hope that you’re going to save a 100 bucks in exchange for taking three extra days to get it done is a net loss.

One of our clients is struggling with this concept right now. Her home is recently vacant and there’s a punch list of items to get it ready for the next resident. The list includes paint, carpet, and then several small handyman type tasks such as installing a towel rack and fixing the slider door latch, replacing the lock sets, things like that. The owner got a second opinion on the carpet and paint. But now she wants a quote on the smaller items, which it’s literally taking, I’m not kidding, an extra 10 days to obtain. At monthly rent of $3,000, that alone is $1,000 in extra lost rent. There is no possible way that a second opinion is going to cost that much less than the first opinion. And in the end, it will be a net loss to the owner.

Meanwhile, on another of our client’s properties, a resident complained about a toilet that was not working properly. It was old, had no flushing power, and this was in a one-bath property. We sent a handyman who replaced the toilet for $375 same day. Problem solved. Efficient repair. Happy residents. The chances of getting that done for $50 cheaper? It’s possible. But even so, the tenants would have been without a properly working toilet for at least another day. There’s no good way to spend that.

Now, how do you know if you should request another estimate? Well, we use the simple rule that we call GSD, for get stuff done. When a vendor is on site and diagnoses a problem, if the cost is less than $500, they are under the instructions to complete that repair, send us the bill. Repair is over $500, they call us directly from on-site so that we can either approve it or get approval from the owner and then let them know whether to proceed before they leave the work site.

For higher price non-emergency issues, there may be another level to deal with and another opinion to request. And in some cases of an emergency, such as a water leak, that $500 threshold takes a back seat. Stopping the damage is the primary concern, even if it costs more than $500. And then we can regroup and consider the rest of the repairs in a more logical, less stressful way.

We dealt with one of these scenarios this week. A resident called and said they had water seeping out from the bottom of both sides of a wall. Our guys were on site the same day. They had the wall opened. They found a water supply line with a pressurized leak. That is a very bad thing. They fixed the pipe. They put fans and a dehumidifier on it right away. And the cost for that initial work was more than $1,500. There was no pre-approval. There was no second opinion. That would have created a much bigger problem and maybe even a mold remediation.

Sometimes you just have to get stuff done and then you avoid the bigger stuff later. Our GSD system saves time and money. It keeps residents happy and in place and it strengthens our handyman relationship, which I can attest absolutely means preferred pricing for our clients. Put it to work, you’ll see the benefits, too.

This wraps up our Maintenance Mastery Series. In part one, we talked about who’s responsible when something breaks at your rental home. Part two was all about why speed matters when it comes to repairs. And part three, we taught you how to budget for repairs on your rental. And today is all about removing bottlenecks and getting stuff done. If you missed any of the previous videos, we’ll include links in the show notes below.

Repairs and maintenance is the most important but often glossed over concern of your rental property. It touches every segment of your tenancy, property and profitability. And if not handled correctly, it can lead to unpleasant legal complications. But now, armed with this information, you can make more informed decisions that help you scale your rental property in the future.

If you have questions about anything you’ve heard here today, call me directly at 951-314-5402. I’m happy to share. You can also find valuable information on our website, dreambigpm.com. And as always, if you found this information useful, please do us a favor and like, subscribe so that we can help others just like you. Don’t be accidental about your future. Be intentional to your success.